Challenging Assumptions blog by Wendy Priesnitz

With Melanie at the Zoo, Fall 2007

Personal Site

Editor-in-Chief of
Life Learning magazine

Editor-in-Chief of 
Natural Life magazine

Editor-in-Chief of
Natural Child magazine

Author of unschooling books

Small/Home Business writer

Poet

Speaker

Interview on Radio Free School

Blog Updates
 What is RSS?

Natural Child magazine

Natural Life magazine

Life Learning Magazine

Challenging Assumptions in Education by Wendy Priesnitz

Bringing it Home - A Home Business Guide by Wendy Priesnitz

School Free - The Homeschooling Handbook by Wendy Priesnitz

Musings, meanderings, wonderings and wanderings about unschooling, natural  parenting, sustainable living and more by Wendy Priesnitz. 

Archives - November, 2007

Exciting New ADHD Research – November 26, 2007
For many years, I have been writing and speaking about the crime of labeling kids as having some mythical disease called ADD or ADHD. In recent years, I’ve been pleased to see others – including Naomi Aldort who writes about the subject in the current issue of Life Learning – take up this cause. But it’s not a popular one, and I have received a lot of verbal abuse on the subject…even had a few canceled subscriptions by people who were indignant that I could suggest these problems weren’t real. I don’t actually suggest that – what I believe is that by the use of these negative labels we are creating medical problems that need solving with medication and that it is harmful, useless and inexcusable to problematize a normal childhood behavior in this manner. As John Holt once put it, there were no learning disorders, only teaching disorders – meaning that the “problem” on surfaces for teachers and parents when children do not fit into the classroom regime. Over the years, I’ve heard from many homeschoolers whose children’s “symptoms” have disappeared when they were sprung from the mind-numbing environment of school.

So I was pleased to see, during my regular perusal of the abstracts of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) for article ideas, a research report that found children who have been “diagnosed” as ADHD just have normal brains that develop later than those of other children. The researchers found that the average age for the maturation of the cerebral cortex was 10.5 years old in ADHD kids, as opposed to 7.5 years old in non-labeled kids.

I think this is a huge finding, so I went searching for commentary on it. There wasn’t much – doctors, educators, many parents (alas) and pharmaceutical companies might not like the ramifications. But Thomas Armstrong, the author of Awakening Your Child’s Natural Genius, The Myth of the A.D.D. Child and many other books, didn’t disappoint me. In his blog about his latest book, Armstrong notes that in working with children who have been subjected to the ADHD label, he has noticed that they act younger and more what is often referred to as “immature” than their peers. In a characteristically gracefully and positively worded posting, he suggests that the word “neoteny” could be used, rather than “immaturity” to capture the vitality of these kids. Neoteny is a Latin word meaning “holding youth” and refers to the retaining of childlike characteristics into adulthood – such as was true for brilliant people like Einstein and Picasso.

So, like me, Armstrong is happy to see the PNAS research report. And he suggests that the kids who are labeled with these so-called disabilities are actually to be admired for being the vanguard in the evolution of our species. Although I’m not sure of the need for any labels, he suggests “evolutionarily gifted.” Now we just have to find a way to convince Neanderthal education systems to evolve away from desks, tests, workbooks, bells, lineups, rules and other old-fashioned creativity-killing bad habits. PNAS is an important journal; here’s hoping some of the professionals who work with kids will read this report and wake up to the damage they’ve been doing and the wonderful possibilities involved with allowing children to be their curious, active, imaginative, playful selves.
Posted: 2007/11/26 2:26 PM

An Alien Education – November 25, 2007
Whenever I have to visit a school I feel like an alien. It started 38 years ago when I became a teacher and continues today. The school model of education is based on such alienating notions as coercion, ageism, standardized assessment, autocracy and what I call the “silo mentality” of separating education from the real world. These principles are frowned upon in the most leading-edge adult organizations and companies, but are still the norm in public schools. So I had a good chuckle when Roland Meighan sent me a link to this new addition to his Personalised Education Now website. It’s an amusing animation of a martian querying an Earth child about schooling.

If you’re not familiar with Roland Meighan’s work, he is a British educational thinker, author and founder of Personalised Education Now and Educational Heretics Press. He has written numerous books on autonomous learning, and contributed a couple of articles to Life Learning Magazine. He supports learner-managed learning, invited rather than uninvited teaching, assessment at the learner’s request and re-integration of learning, life and community.
Posted: 2007/11/25 1:35 PM

When School Stinks – November 25, 2007
A new high school was built in Halifax recently. Two older schools were closed and their students moved to the new one. As often happens with construction, the new school took longer to build than planned. So, when school began in September there were still some things to finish, like the ventilation system and the off-gassing of formaldehyde-laden particleboard furniture, carpets and equipment. In spite of the concerns of and advice from a “healthy-school consultant,” students and teachers were subjected to this indoor air pollution. And now, almost three months later, they are still complaining of headaches, itchy eyes and breathing problems. According to air quality tests, there are high levels of volatile organic compounds – released from products such as new furniture, construction materials and cleaners – in the school.

Some of the teachers are, according to media reports, staying home. Students don’t (always) have that choice. An education official told the press: “You can only delay the start of school so long before you start impacting on the school year.” Strange priorities.
Posted: 2007/11/25 12:31 PM

New Address –  November 21, 2007
If you have this page bookmarked or if you subscribe to the RSS feed, you might want  to update  it. I have just moved my blog from the Life Media website to my own WendyPriesnitz.com. For now, you will be automatically redirected, but that will eventually end. 
Posted: 2007/11/21 8:03 PM

Shopping to Save the Planet – November 21, 2007
Shopping is a complicated issue. Some people do it to combat boredom or stress; some people are addicted to it; some people don’t have the money to do it. (I recently read about a woman who took her kids to the local second-hand store every Saturday morning to “shop” – they wander the store, put a bunch of stuff they’d like into a cart, then put it all back because they can’t afford it…) Some people think they can shop to save the planet from global warming. And at least one person thinks that those shoppers are women.

Simon Fanshawe, writing in the UK-based magazine Green Futures suggests that male-dominated governments have been destroying the planet for too long, and now women need to clean up the mess. And, since we already control the majority of the shopping decisions, all we need to do is buy the right foods, shoes and handbags. Fanshawe is referencing a serious initiative on the part of two British organizations – the National Federation of Women’s Institutes and the Women’s Environmental Network – which have launched the Women’s Manifesto on Climate Change. And, yes, women may be more inclined than men to initiate and value small, personal and family-based changes, which is an approach I’ve long championed in the pages of Natural Life Magazine. But Fanshawe’s article highlights something I’ve also been saying since the latest wave of environmental concern surfaced awhile back: While ethical consumerism is important, we can’t shop our way out of the problem.

Writing in the Guardian newspaper last summer, British writer George Monbiot cynically derided ethical shopping as “just another way of showing how rich you are.” For the record, I may be the only person on the planet who dislikes that highly opinionated man and his best selling book Heat…well, actually I couldn’t stomach his attitude enough to finish reading the darn thing. But I do agree with him on that point. If I receive one more cute little miniature recycling box or one more supposedly biodegradable plastic pen from a PR firm, I’ll have to move out of my house to make room for all the “eco-junk.”

That has been defined as the Sixth Sin of Greenwashing in a just released study by TerraChoice Environmental Marketing. They’re the company that administers the EcoLogo marketing program begun in 1988 by the Canadian government. They say that the Sin of Lesser of Two Evils, illustrated as organic cigarettes or a hybrid-yet-inefficient SUV, occurred in one percent of the 1,000 products they tested. Unfortunately, 99 percent of the products were, they say, guilty of greenwashing or stretching the eco-truth. The study and details about the other “sins” can be found on their website. So shopping ethically ain’t easy, folks, even if it might do some good.

Fanshawe says that we will probably have to define ourselves less by what we buy, and more by how we behave, to make a real change. So the solution is to buy less stuff, not just substitute green junk for non-green junk. Perhaps the best immediate choice is to celebrate Buy Nothing Day this Friday!
Posted: 2007/11/21 2:03 PM

Sharing the Pleasure of Books – November 19, 2007
I’m always skeptical about reports like the one released today by the National Endowment for the Arts, suggesting that people (in this case Americans) are reading less. In spite of the increase in the number of teen fiction books and the Harry Potter phenomenon, this study claims that young people are reading fewer books voluntarily and comprehending less.

Some of my skepticism relates to the fact that computer use is seen as a villain rather than an alternative source of words to be read, and that comprehension is based on my old enemy standardized tests. But I am happy to read that NEA chairman Dana Gioia feels this supposed decline in reading is an important socio-economic issue and is calling for changes “in the way we’re educating kids, especially in high school and college. We need to reconnect reading with pleasure and enlightenment.” Now there’s an earth-shattering idea!

Of course, it’s an idea that unschoolers have known about all along. And a couple in Ottawa has created a terrific tool for families who like to read. It’s a children’s book podcast called Just One More Book! Three times a week, Andrea Ross and Mark Blevis sit at a table in their favorite coffee shop and record their conversation about the children’s books their family (they have two young daughters) loves and why they love them. They also feature weekly interviews with authors, literacy related discussions and audio reviews submitted by listeners. Episodes range in length from five to 30 minutes and can be played directly from the website or downloaded to an iPod for listening on the go. Through this podcast and its website, this family is building a lively, interactive community linking children’s book authors, illustrators, readers (parents and children) and publishers. Here’s to reading for pleasure and enlightenment! (Oh, and thanks for reading this blog...even if it is not a book.)
Posted: 2007/11/19 9:05 AM

Keep On Rockin’ in a Free World – November 12, 2007
OK, so I like jazz and Mozart and Bach and women singers. But I also love listening to Neil Young. There’s a part of me from the late ’60s and early ’70s that still resonates with his nasal, sometimes ragged, evocative and personal lyrics and burn-out guitar. The fact that he’s Canadian, born here in Toronto – living and working in the USA but never giving up his citizenship – is now a bonus. Doesn’t hurt that he is also an outspoken advocate for environmental issues and small farmers, having co-founded the benefit concert Farm Aid.

Neil Young has provided one of the soundtracks of my life, from the early Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young days when the harmony and sentiment in “Teach Your Children” took my 19-year-old breath away, through the protest songs like the Kent State massacre tune “Ohio” and “Rockin’ in the Free World, to the album After the Gold Rush with “Only Love Can Break Your Heart”, the Harvest album (1971) with “Old Man” and “Heart of Gold,” which is his only number one hit single and features the back-up vocals of some of my other nostalgic favorite singer/song writers James Taylor and Linda Ronstadt, and “Comes a Time” in 1977. Oh, wait, maybe I like Harvest Moon better: “But there’s a full moon risin’, Let’s go dancin in the light, We know where the music’s playin’, Let’s go out and feel the night.” Every song on that album is a hit in my mind. Or maybe I prefer Are You Passionate? (2002), an album of love songs dedicated to his wife Pegi. Somebody once suggested that I liked his music because he often sings off-key, which makes it easy for me (who has trouble holding a tune) to sing along! Perhaps.

We’re all getting older, of course. Today’s Neil Young’s 62nd birthday and a couple of years ago he was treated for a brain auerysm and we thought he’d burnt out. But he survived to record Prairie Wind. Today, I’ve been having a musical party for him while I work. Keep on rockin’, Neil.
Posted: 2007/11/12 7:50 PM

Enlightened Homemaking – November 12, 2007
In the weekend papers, I read a profile of an interesting woman named Shannon Hayes. She has a BA in creative writing from Binghamton University, and a masters and Ph.D. in sustainable agriculture and community development from Cornell University. But when she finished her post-grad work, she rejected the “Supermom” ideal of blending family and career. So she and her husband joined her family to run a grassfed livestock farm, planted perennial beds and an organic garden, and as she puts it, “began pursuing an authentic life – one where we lived by our principles.” The rest of her story can be found on her website, but the point here is that she became a Supermom anyway – replacing over-achievement in a conventional career with over-achievement in her career as a mom, writer, “simple liver” and environmental activist.

She is part of a trend (although some of us lived this way 30 years ago). And she is writing about that trend: Her next book will profile people like her – either male or female – who have sidestepped a traditional career to put family and planet first. She calls us “enlightened homemakers.” You can contact Shannon about being interviewed through her website.
Posted: 2007/11/12 1:28 PM

Creating a Relevant College Education – November 6, 2007
One of my daughters runs a botanical garden affiliated with Acadia University in Wolfville, Nova Scotia. Maya Frost has a daughter who attends Acadia. The Acadia faculty has been on strike for three weeks. And that’s how Maya and I “met.” Maya was writing about the strike on her Free Agent U blog and so I stumbled upon this fascinating writer, consultant and world citizen. Although her office is located in Oregon, she is currently living in Buenos Aires, Argentina with her husband and varying combinations of her four daughters. Aside from noticing her work as a “mindfulness trainer” (mindfulness is a mission for me), the title of the book she’s writing caught my eye. It’s called Free Agent U: Skip the SAT, Save Thousands On Tuition, and Get An Outrageously Relevant College Education. There’s lot of info on and connected to her blog about the book, but basically, it’s about finding ways to get a good education in non-traditional ways…and “good” includes “multilingual and globally relevant.” It also means avoiding the angst-filled, hyper-competitive but ultimately meaningless high stakes testing path. Great to find other people who are dedicated to helping people learn what they want and need to know, rather than what others tell them they need. Check it out.
Posted: 2007/11/06 12:38 PM

Return to current weblog
Comments? Suggestions? Email Us

copyright © Wendy Priesnitz 2007

Topics & Passions:

natural learning
simplicity
environment
parenting
creativity / writing
books

~

What I'm Reading:

The Geography of Hope - A Tour of the World We Need by Chris Turner (Random House Canada, 2007)
A Thousand Names  for Joy: Living in Harmony with the Way Things Are
by Byron Katie (Harmony Books, 2007)

~

What I'm Listening To: 

Gold by Nina Simone (Sony Universal Music, 2007)
Hounds of Love by Kate Bush (EMI,  1997)
Mozart Concertos for Piano by Maria Joao Pires (Erato, 1978)
The Art of Romance by Tony Bennett (Columbia Records, 2004)

~

Fav Bookmarks:

Daughter Blog
Junkyard Sports
Radio Free School
Parenting Without Punishing
The Guardian
Organic Consumers Association
Free2be
Common Dreams
Grist Magazine
Just One More Book!

~

Fav Quotes:

Art, Writing, Creativity
Life and Living
Men and Women
Learning
Environment and Peace