Editor of
Life Learning magazine

Editor of 
Natural Life magazine

Author of unschooling books

Small/Home Business writer

Poet

Speaker


 

 

 

 

Musings, meanderings, wonderings and wanderings about unschooling, natural  parenting, sustainable living and more by Wendy Priesnitz. 

Archives - February, 2007

Another Reason Not to Send Them to School – February 22, 2007
You might remember a couple of summers ago the media reported an investigation by the California-based Center for Environmental Health (CEH) that found lead contamination in children’s vinyl lunchboxes. Just weeks after the CEH test results were released, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CSPC) announced that its testing showed no lead problems from lunchboxes. Now, I’ve received a press release from CEH stating that it has government documents, obtained under Freedom of Information legislation, showing that at the time CPSC made its announcement, its own laboratory testing showed that vinyl lunchboxes had levels of lead as much as 16 times higher than those allowed in paint. Even worse, the documents reveal that at the time the agency was about to announce that lead lunchboxes are safe, CPSC had just changed its testing procedure in an apparent effort to minimize findings of lead in lunchboxes.

“CPSC told parents that these lunchboxes were safe, but their own tests showed that lead in these lunchboxes could pose a threat to children,” says Michael Green, Executive Director of CEH. “It is shocking to see an agency entrusted with our safety playing Russian roulette with our children’s health.”

Since its initial investigation, CEH has tested hundreds of lunchboxes bought from store shelves and received from concerned parents, and has initiated legal action against the retailers and manufacturers of these dangerous products. Through this litigation, CEH has created industry-wide reformulation of vinyl lunchboxes to eliminate lead threats to children, in groundbreaking settlements with 15 manufactures and retailers of vinyl lunchboxes. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration also last year issued a warning to manufacturers of vinyl lunchboxes, advising them to eliminate the use of vinyl in lunchbox interiors. Ironically, FDA based their recommendation in part on CPSC’s test results. Mind boggling.
Posted: 2007/02/22 8:04 PM

Green and Growing – February 21, 2007
The fear factor is at work again and I, for one, am very tired of it. So, apparently is British climate change economist Sir Nicholas Stern, who told the media yesterday in Toronto that governments are wrong to argue that combating climate change will create economic hardship. “You can be green and grow,” Stern said. “I do not think it’s a horse race between growth and being responsible on climate change. Good policy can give us both.”

In fact, he said, the costs of action to correct global warming are far less than the costs of inaction. But politicians are busy telling us that we can’t make greenhouse gas emission reduction targets without risking economic collapse. Canada’s new Environment Minister John Baird said just two weeks ago that the country “should brace itself for an economic hit when limits are imposed on emissions from industrial polluters.” Stern, a former chief economist at the World Bank, admitted cutting global greenhouse emissions by 30 percent by 2050 would cost about one percent of the world’s economic output. However, he said, the cost of failing to act could be as much as 20 times higher. Meanwhile, Canada’s emissions continue to rise and are currently about 34 percent higher than the goal.

I’m hopeful that the recent rise in public interest in fixing our environmental errors will force governments to get moving. But the auto and oil industries (and their respective unions,) to name just two sources of greenhouse gas emissions, aren’t going to appreciate being forced to redefine themselves. So it will take bold and unwavering action backed up by a strong conviction – not things most politicians are known for. However, I think that we may be reaching a tipping point and that many people are ready to accept much greater change than the politicians give us credit for. So get on the phone to your elected representative today and tell him or her you want them to put away the green paintbrush and start to take real action on climate change. Fast, while there is still a future for our children and grandchildren.
Posted: 2007/02/21 3:50 PM

The Messy Room – February 18, 2007
Rolf and I were straightening up our basement and moved a brass daybed belonging to our daughter Melanie from one side of the room to another. As we do whenever we move the darn thing, we chuckled as we reminisced about its history. Rolf had promised it to Melanie when she was a child if only she would keep her bedroom neat for a year. Since it’s now in our basement, the bribery obviously worked, although I didn’t particularly agree with it at the time and don’t recommend it now. And I don’t think there is any connection between the bed and the fact that Melanie now lives in a neat house. (However, I often think that perhaps someone should have made the same offer to her dad at some point, because he still hasn’t learned to clean up his piles of clothes!) At any rate, our discussion reminded me of a humorous article that we published in Natural Life magazine’s Natural Child column back in 1997. It was written by British Columbia homeschooler Linda Boulter and entitled “The Messy Room.” Linda concluded with these wise words: “In the end, the key is that they do learn. And we learn that learning cannot be imposed from without because it only has true value when it comes from within.”
Posted: 2007/02/18 5:58 PM

Supporting Homeschooling in Germany – February 12, 2007
Writing is hard. It’s always hard, but this morning it’s been harder than usual. I recently agreed to write a letter of encouragement to German homeschoolers, to be presented at a gathering being held there later this year. I’ve been keeping informed about the awful persecution of homeschoolers that’s been happening in Germany, where homeschooling is illegal. The most recent case involves a 15-year-old forcibly confined to a mental institution and removed from her parents’ custody!

But in spite of the seriousness of the problem, I have found the letter incredibly difficult to compose. Although I’m very sure of the desirability of learning without schooling, I am also conscious of not knowing much about Germany’s current politics, culture or education system, even though my husband Rolf was born there and still has family there. So I can’t presume to know how to fix the situation.

I can share what helped here when I began advocating for homeschooling back in the mid 1970s (although it was legal here, so we were starting from a different place) and that is what I began to do. However, as I researched the German situation, I quickly understood just how complex it is, in spite of some attempts by outsiders to distill it into a war between Nazis, socialists and Christians. (Here is a good history and commentary from Home Education magazine columnist Valerie Bonham Moon.) And I also began to realize that while I can most certainly share my concern and philosophical support, there must be a made-in-Germany solution to the problem. But how to communicate that, while providing moral support and not seeming to dismiss the awful problems of this nascent homeschooling community? Like I said, writing is hard.
Posted: 2007/02/12 11:27 AM

Who Creates the Structure? – February 11, 2007
Thanks to readers for some lovely bits of feedback about my unstructured play posting, mostly reminiscences of outdoor childhood games that were gloriously free of rules and adult supervision. However, as a friend sadly reminded me, there are now many situations where it is dangerous for children to play without some adult supervision, if not structure.

The term “unstructured” is probably misleading. “Self-directed” might be a better choice because, of course, everything – play, learning, life – has some sort of structure (thanks for the reminder, Sandra!). The issue for me is not whether something has structure, but who is in control of creating the structure. Play is, I think, a state of freedom…of movement, action, exploration, enjoyment. As such, it is inherently both unstructured and self-directed. Anything else probably isn’t play.
Posted: 2007/02/11 2:45 PM

Too Busy Playing  – February 8, 2007
I have received a couple of responses to yesterday’s post about Baby Einstein. They’ve all been along the same lines of some critical letters sent to us at Life Learning a few years back after we published an article about the Alliance for Childhood’s study about children and computers. In addition to pointing out that unschooled children use television and computers differently, in a different context, than schooled kids, Pieter from Los Angeles suggests that I’m being inconsistent with an article in Life Learning’s current issue entitled “Fear of TV Beast.” That piece, by Julie Persons, describes how she and her husband gave up restricting television and allowed their son to watch as much as he wanted. But there is a world of difference between parents buying Baby Einstein and its ilk (which Mendizza calls “junk food for the developing brain”) in order to supposedly kickstart their babies’ intelligence and trusting an older child’s ability to choose quality activities for him/herself.

Person’s son eventually gravitated away from the TV and toward other play activities, as Mendizza suggests children will. And that’s because they are hard-wired to play. Unlike adults, for whom play is something to be done when more important jobs are finished, children live to play. And it’s crucial to their development. Unfortunately, unstructured play makes many parents fearful that their children are wasting precious time. And so they try to control that play and create or buy products that make the “work” of learning seem like “fun.”

I’m working on some articles about the value of unstructured play for a future issue of Life Learning and welcome input or contributions.
Posted: 2007/02/08 1:49 PM

Too Busy Learning From the Real World – February 7, 2007
In his recent State of the Union address, the U.S. President applauded Julie Aigner-Clark, founder of Baby Einstein for her entrepreneurial and philanthropic spirit. I guess it’s a huge honor for a business person, especially a woman, to be mentioned in such an important speech, so congratulations are due to Aigner-Clark, whose business was bought by Disney in 2001. But I’ve always had a problem with Baby Einstein and other such concepts that fall into the “infant developmental media products” category. So I was pleased to see documentary film-maker and author Michael Mendizza ranting against them in his recent newsletter.

He wrote: “Baby Einstein, however, is one of my Orwellian ‘double speak’ pet peeves, for there exists compelling evidence that the more time a young child spends watching Baby Einstein the less like Einstein that child will become.” He goes on to note that Einstein’s imagination was fueled by reading descriptive language, not by watching pictures flash by on a screen, which is a sensory experience (like skipping rope) rather than an imaginative one. In fact, he claims, “Babies would never buy Baby Einstein videos. They are too busy playing and learning from the real world.”

Mendizza has posted an article on the subject, entitled Just Say No to Baby Einstein on his Touch the Future website.
Posted: 2007/02/07 4:10 PM

Molly Ivins Will be Missed – February 4, 2007
“We are the people who run this country. We are the deciders. And every single day, every single one of us needs to step outside and take some action to help stop this war. Raise hell. Think of something to make the ridiculous look ridiculous. Make our troops know we're for them and trying to get them out of there…We need people in the streets, banging pots and pans and demanding, ‘Stop it, now!’” That’s how the progressive author and syndicated political columnist Molly Ivins ended her last column on Alternet a few weeks ago. This past week, she died after a long battle with breast cancer at age 62.

Molly Ivins was an eloquent writer and speaker, with a large dose of down-to-earth wit…and one of the women journalists who has inspired me over the years. She was bold, insightful, outspoken, even outrageous at times (in 1991, she wrote a book called Molly Ivins Can’t Say That – Can She?), passionate about writing and a champion of liberal causes and the underdogs of society. She was also a master of satire, which she aimed mostly at politicians – George W. Bush being one of her favorite targets in recent years. She wrote famously: “The next time I tell you someone from Texas should not be president of the United States, please, pay attention.” Born in California, she considered herself a Texan, working at a number of Texas papers over the years, as well as The New York Times. Her writing will be missed; we need more voices like hers these days.

One of my favorite Ivins quotes is: “What you need is sustained outrage...there’s far too much unthinking respect given to authority.” Here are some more.
Posted: 2007/02/04 7:54 PM

It May Not Be Too Late – February 4, 2007
Canada’s Prime Minister Stephen Harper has appeared startled by the depth of Canadians’ concern about the environment. He has done a complete turnabout, suddenly painting his relatively new, right wing minority government green in a cynical response to negative reactions to the slashing it had done to environmental programs just months earlier. I am skeptical about the depth of his commitment to the climate change problem, given that his base of power is in the oil country of Alberta. And he’s already muddying up that new green paint by saying emission cuts are unrealistic and emission stabilization is more practical. But what is really astounding is how guys like Harper, his buddy George W. Bush and Tony Blair have underestimated the problem and misread voters’ serious level of concern about the precarious state of our Planet’s health. Perhaps they’re to be excused, since the tipping point has come about in a remarkably short time.

I am seeing a huge and sudden increase in the number of people wanting to learn to live sustainably, as demonstrated by the rising sales of subscriptions to Natural Life magazine. Sales of everything organic, energy-efficient and otherwise green are skyrocketing. Corporations are realizing that sustainable business can be profitable. I’m hoping the momentum can be continued, making 2007 the year that citizens, governments and the business sector alike mobilize to save the Planet. Never have the opportunities been greater, but never have the stakes been higher.

And for that reason, look for the conservative naysayers – funded by the fossil fuel industries – to rev up their activities. With the release of the UN’s latest climate change report, they have begun creating a cloud of PR pollution, trying to convince voters to convince the bandwagon-jumping politicians that climate change is just part of a normal cycle and isn’t caused by human activity…and therefore the lucrative activities of big commerce shouldn’t be obstructed in its name. Be wary of groups with obfuscating names like Natural Resources Stewardship Project and Friends of Science trying to convince you that you won’t like the economic fall-out from sustainability. Dinosaurs can make a loud noise as they fall.

One of the places to monitor the activities of the dinosaurs is DeSmogBlog.
Posted: 2007/02/04 12:04 PM

Broadening Their Horizons – February 1, 2007
From time to time, a misguided parent finds what he/she regards as an objectionable book in their child’s backpack and goes running to the school or local library with censorship on their mind. The latest incident that I’ve heard about took place recently in a Toronto suburb. The Peel Catholic school board has pulled the award-winning novel Snow Falling on Cedars from high school library shelves after one parent complained about its sexual content. School officials were quick to point out that the 12-year-old book, which has been the subject of controversy and bans in the U.S. as well, hasn’t been banned…although what else can one call it if the book isn’t available to students?

This is a novel about significant social issues like racism and morality.  Its content is pretty innocuous compared to what’s available to teens on the Internet and in movies (and the book was actually made into an Oscar-nominated film.) And there is, for me, a fascinating irony here. The author is David Guterson. He was a high school English teacher before he was able to support himself as a novelist. And, as the father of four, he was/is a homeschooler whose book Family Matters: Why Homeschooling Makes Sense was first published in 1992. In it, he talks about the complete breakdown of our school systems, including their increasing social irrelevancy. I don’t remember if he talked about censorship specifically, but his idea of homeschooling (a term that he said he hoped would disappear from use, a sentiment with which I heartily agree) is to broaden his children’s horizons, which includes allowing culture to have a life outside of classrooms. Try to tell  that to the censors...parents and school officials alike.
Posted: 2007/02/01 11:48 AM

Return to current weblog
Comments? Suggestions? Email Us

copyright © Wendy Priesnitz 2007

Topics & Passions:

natural learning
simplicity
environment
parenting
creativity / writing
books

~

What I'm Reading:

Moral Minds by Marc D. Hauser (HarperCollins, 2006)
Home Schooling in Full View - A Reader
edited by Bruce S. Cooper (Information Age Publishing, 2005)
Saving Energy, Growing Jobs
by David B. Goldstein (Bay Tree Publishing, 2007)

~

What I'm Listening To: 

The Band: The Last Waltz  (Warner Bros., 2003)
Bach Violin Concertos
by Itzhak Perlman and Pinchas Zukerman with the English Chamber Orchestra (EMI, 2001)
Solo Piano - Ten Performances
(Fringe Jazz Toronto, 2004)
Half the Perfect World
by Madeleine Peyroux (Rounder Records, 2006)

~

Fav Bookmarks:

Daughter Blog
Moon and Me - Bringing Nature and Nurture Together
Parenting Without Punishing
Organic Consumers Association
Free2be
Common Dreams
Grist Magazine

~

Fav Quotes:

Art, Writing, Creativity
Life and Living
Men and Women
Learning
Environment and Peace